Objective 7-1
Recognize that a fallacy that does not rest on an illegitimate appeal to emotion often works by garbling the structure of a good argument. Objective 7-2
Understand the basic concept entailed in every variety of ad hominem fallacy and why it makes for a bad argument. - Understand that good reasoning depends on a clear and steadily maintained distinction between the person making a claim and the claim itself.
- Differentiate among the most common breeds of ad hominem fallacies: the personal attack, the inconsistency ad hominem, the circumstantial ad hominem, poisoning the well, the genetic fallacy, and also certain positive ad hominem fallacies.
Objective 7-3
Understand how certain fallacies begin with sound principles of logic or argumentation and only distort or misapply them. - Recognize the fallacy known as the straw man and understand the difference between it and the legitimate refutation of a contrary position.
- Identify varieties of the false dilemma, which begins with a rational principle about alternatives.
- See the difference between a false dilemma and its logical (non-fallacious) counterpart.
- Differentiate among the false dilemma itself and the related perfectionist fallacy and the line-drawing fallacy.
Objective 7-4
Understand the type of fallacy commonly called "slippery slope" and how to identify examples of it. - Realize that a reliance on unfounded claims (about what leads to what else) is the telling mark that makes an argument a case of the slippery slope.
Objective 7-5
Understand the kinds of fallacies that have to do with illogical refusals to give arguments in exactly those situations that call for arguments. - Understand the fallacy of misplacing the burden of proof, and be able to identify it.
- Learn the rules that help to specify which side of a given issue actually has the burden of proof.
- Understand the role of initial plausibility in determining the burden of proof.
- Understand the very special case of illogicality known as begging the question, and how to spot instances of begged questions.
|